Student visa tracking is not right response

EDITORIAL BOARD Editor in
Chief
 Timothy Kudo

Managing Editor
 Michael Falcone

Viewpoint Editor
 Cuauhtemoc Ortega

Staff Representatives
 Amanda Fletcher
 Kelly Rayburn
 Marcelle Richards
Vytas Mazeika
Corey McEleney
Linh Tat

Editorial Board Assistants
 Maegan Carberry
 Edward Chiao

  Unsigned editorials represent a majority opinion of
the Daily Bruin Editorial Board. All other columns, letters and
artwork represent the opinions of their authors.   All
submitted material must bear the author’s name, address, telephone
number, registration number, or affiliation with UCLA. Names will
not be withheld except in extreme cases.   The Bruin
complies with the Communication Board’s policy prohibiting the
publication of articles that perpetuate derogatory cultural or
ethnic stereotypes.   When multiple authors submit
material, some names may be kept on file rather than published with
the material. The Bruin reserves the right to edit submitted
material and to determine its placement in the paper. All
submissions become the property of The Bruin. The Communications
Board has a media grievance procedure for resolving complaints
against any of its publications. For a copy of the complete
procedure, contact the Publications office at 118 Kerckhoff Hall.
Daily Bruin 118 Kerckhoff Hall 308 Westwood Plaza Los Angeles, CA
90024 (310) 825-9898

Fortunately for international students hoping to enter American
schools, Sen. Dianne Feinstein, D-Calif., has abandoned her plan
for a six-month moratorium on student visas.

But current and prospective international students
shouldn’t breathe a sigh of relief just yet ““ she plans
to have them electronically tracked by government agencies and has
asked President George W. Bush to allocate $32.2 million in
emergency funds to do it.

This electronic tracking plan was in the works long before Sept.
11 as a result of the 1996 Immigration Reform and Responsibility
Act. The computer database is supposed to be operational by 2003.
But since two of the terrorists were in the United States on
student visas, Feinstein thinks the “threat” of
terrorists manipulating the student visa system merits immediate,
emergency-level scrutiny. Feinstein hopes the federal funds will
fast track the system’s implementation.

However, this is a rash reaction to the widespread fear of
terrorism.

True, the fact that two of the hijackers were here on student
visas warrants more thorough security measures like comprehensive
background checks for student visa applicants.

The new role of the INS in Feinstein’s plan should be
limited to registering student visa applicants, conducting
preliminary background checks and carrying out deportations when
necessary. After that, it’s the duty of the CIA and FBI to
routinely gather intelligence about anyone ““ regardless of
whether or not they are international students ““ posing
terrorist threats.

While the INS may be able to help the FBI manage the 2 percent
of visa holders who are students by tracking them after the fact,
the situation can wait.

It seems more reasonable for universities housing international
students to make regular reports on their enrollment status to the
INS, which university representatives have publically agreed to do.
In fact, their agreement is the reason Feinstein has called off her
dogs on granting international student visas.

If universities are willing to report on the status of students,
there’s no reason to spend $32.2 million on an electronic
tracking system, especially since student information is kept on
paper already.

Rather than funding a potentially discriminatory information
system, the government needs to use those funds to advance New
York’s recovery, ease unemployment, and subsidize struggling
American industries.

Ultimately, we may be able to track people but we cannot track
their intentions. We might comfort ourselves knowing fewer people
are being allowed into the country through student visas, but we
need to remember that terrorists come from all nationalities,
including American.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *